Replacing actors with AI is "dumb as hell," says Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 and Baldur's Gate 3 star Jennifer English, because "humanness" is what makes these RPGs "so beloved"

March 3, 2026 - 22:05

In a passionate defense of artistic authenticity, acclaimed voice actor Jennifer English has labeled the concept of replacing performers with artificial intelligence as "dumb as hell." The star of Baldur's Gate 3 and the upcoming Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 argues that the unique humanity actors bring is irreplaceable and fundamental to the success of narrative-driven games.

"I find it all a bit embarrassing and stupid, frankly," English stated, addressing the growing industry debate. She emphasized that the subtle imperfections, emotional intuition, and collaborative spirit of human performers are what forge a genuine connection with audiences. It is this very "humanness," she contends, that makes role-playing games so deeply beloved, as players invest in characters that feel alive and authentically realized.

English’s comments highlight a critical concern within the entertainment field as AI tools advance. Her perspective underscores that performance is more than just delivering lines; it's an act of shared creation and emotional truth. For many developers and fans, the soul of a character-driven story lies in the nuanced work of the actor behind the voice, something she believes technology cannot replicate without losing the heart of the art form. The discussion continues as the industry grapples with balancing innovation with the preservation of core creative values.