Critics Highlight These Must-Play Releases

2 January 2026

Gamers, buckle up! Whether you’re a joystick wizard or a casual button-masher, the gaming world has been on fire lately. Critics have been buzzing like bees about some insane releases that absolutely demand your attention. These aren’t just your everyday game drops—they’re the ones reviewers can’t stop gushing over. We're talking groundbreaking gameplay, jaw-dropping visuals, and stories that grip you harder than a cliffhanger at the end of your favorite TV show.

In this post, we’re diving deep into the hottest, most hyped, critically acclaimed games that have taken the industry by storm. So grab your headset, sit back, and let’s power up on the must-play titles that critics are raving about.

🎮 Why Critic-Approved Games Matter

Before we get into the list, let’s break it down—why do critic-approved games even matter? It’s not just about fancy scores on Metacritic or IGN.

Think about it: Critics spend hours reviewing mechanics, storytelling, performance, and replay value. They’re like food critics with a refined taste, and when they say something’s top-tier, it’s worth checking out. These releases usually set new standards, break molds, and redefine what gaming can be.

So when critics highlight a game, chances are there's something truly special under the hood.

🔥 1. Elden Ring – A Masterclass in Open-World Design

From Software struck gold yet again with Elden Ring. Imagine Dark Souls had a lovechild with The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild—that’s Elden Ring in a nutshell.

Critics hailed it as a genre-defining masterpiece, combining rich lore, punishing-yet-rewarding combat, and one of the most immersive open worlds ever crafted. It’s dark, it’s beautiful, and it’s dangerously addicting.

Why it stands out:
- Completely non-linear exploration
- Deep character customization
- Cooperative multiplayer mixed with PvP combat
- A haunting, mysterious world that begs to be uncovered

If you’ve got a thing for challenging gameplay and jaw-dropping landscapes, this one’s a no-brainer.

🛡️ 2. The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom – Nintendo’s Crown Jewel

You didn’t think Nintendo was going to let the gaming crown slip off its head, did you? Tears of the Kingdom, the direct sequel to Breath of the Wild, not only lived up to the hype—it soared beyond expectations.

Critics were all over it, praising its seamless combination of puzzle-solving, combat, storytelling, and player freedom.

Why critics love it:
- Expands the open-world concept with vertical exploration
- Crafting and building system that lets you go wild
- Nostalgic nods to classic Zelda while pushing new ideas

It’s Zelda, but supercharged. Whether you're a longtime fan or a newcomer, this game is pure magic.

👾 3. Resident Evil 4 Remake – Horror Reimagined

Capcom has been on a remake spree, but Resident Evil 4 Remake might just be their magnum opus. Critics praised the game for capturing the essence of the 2005 classic while giving it a modern upgrade that feels completely fresh.

What makes it a must-play:
- Stunning graphics with ray-tracing support
- Improved controls and AI
- Enhanced storytelling and deeper character development
- That perfect balance between action and horror

This isn’t just old-school nostalgia. It’s terror with a brand-new polish—and it’s downright addictive.

🚀 4. Starfield – Bethesda’s Space Odyssey

When Bethesda finally dropped Starfield, it was like Christmas came early for RPG lovers. Critics noted that while it took a few steps from the Skyrim playbook, it launched us into a universe filled with endless possibilities.

Yeah, there were bugs (it’s a Bethesda game, after all), but the sheer scale and ambition won critics over.

Why it’s making waves:
- Over 1000 explorable planets
- Intricate faction-based storytelling
- Deep ship customization and space combat
- Role-playing elements that feel genuinely personal

If you’ve ever wanted to be a space pirate, explorer, or even a galactic diplomat, this game gives you the keys to the galaxy.

🌀 5. Alan Wake 2 – A Psychological Thriller Done Right

Remedy’s return to the eerie town of Bright Falls with Alan Wake 2 delivered chills, twists, and some serious narrative swagger.

Critics applauded its storytelling depth, atmospheric tension, and cinematic presentation that felt like binge-watching an award-winning mystery series—with the bonus of being in control.

Why critics couldn’t get enough:
- Dual protagonists with intertwining stories
- Beautifully creepy visual design
- Puzzle elements that reward exploration
- Nail-biting horror sequences without relying on cheap jump scares

It’s not just a game—it’s an experience. And one you shouldn’t miss if you appreciate haunting narratives.

🏐 6. Baldur’s Gate 3 – The Ultimate RPG Revival

Who knew a Dungeons & Dragons-inspired game would turn out to be one of the year’s best? Baldur’s Gate 3 took the gaming world by storm with its insane level of depth and freedom.

Critics didn’t just love it—they adored it. One reviewer even called it "the gold standard for modern RPGs."

What makes it shine:
- Deep character relationships and branching dialogues
- Turn-based combat with tactical complexity
- Choices that matter—really matter
- Rich world-building that rewards curiosity

For fans of RPGs, this one’s a dream come true. It’s like playing a D&D campaign with a hyper-intelligent DM who never runs out of ideas.

🧙 7. Hogwarts Legacy – A Magical Open-World Adventure

Whether you’re Ravenclaw or Slytherin, Hogwarts Legacy had something for every Potterhead. Critics were skeptical at first, but the game delivered an enchanting experience with a unique take on the Wizarding World.

Why critics gave it a thumbs up:
- A massive, detailed rendition of Hogwarts and beyond
- Original story set in the 1800s
- Spell-based combat that evolves over time
- Memorable side quests and magical creatures

It’s not perfect, but it’s the closest you’ll get to living your own Harry Potter fantasy. And let’s be honest—who doesn’t want to ride a broomstick?

⚔️ 8. Lies of P – A Pinocchio Tale Turned Dark Souls

Who would’ve guessed that reimagining Pinocchio as a gritty, Soulsborne-style action RPG would work? Lies of P came out of nowhere and blew critics away with its inventive setting and tight, responsive combat.

Here’s why it clicks:
- Unique narrative twist on a childhood classic
- Steampunk aesthetics that feel fresh and immersive
- High-stakes, skill-based combat
- Rewarding progression system

It’s like if Tim Burton and FromSoftware had a game baby—and trust me, that odd combo totally works.

🦾 9. Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty – A Redemption Arc Worth Playing

Yes, Cyberpunk 2077 had a rough start. But Phantom Liberty, the major expansion, brought the game roaring back into the good graces of critics.

Why it made the must-play list:
- Revamped mechanics and AI improvements
- Idris Elba’s unforgettable performance as Solomon Reed
- Gritty spy-thriller story that adds depth
- Additional areas that feel fully fleshed out

Critics saw it as a redemption arc done right. If you skipped Cyberpunk at launch, now’s the perfect time to dive in.

⛩️ 10. Ghost of Tsushima: Director’s Cut – Eastern Elegance Reimagined

Okay, technically a re-release, but Ghost of Tsushima: Director’s Cut gave critics a reason to fall in love all over again.

Why it’s still worth your time:
- New Iki Island expansion with powerful storytelling
- Enhanced visuals and DualSense features (PS5)
- Refined combat and stealth mechanics
- A breathtaking world inspired by feudal Japan

This isn't just a game—it’s a love letter to samurai culture. Plus, that photo mode? Chef’s kiss.

🎯 What Makes a Game "Must-Play" in 2024?

So, what’s the secret sauce behind these critically acclaimed hits?

It's a mix of:

- Original storytelling: Games that aren’t afraid to be bold and tell stories in unusual ways.
- Polished mechanics: Tight controls, refined gameplay loops, and minimal filler content.
- Imagination: New worlds you want to get lost in, characters you fall for, and experiences that stick with you.

These aren’t just games. They’re events. And critics have tossed their hats in the air like it’s graduation day.

🎮 Final Thoughts – Time to Clear Your Backlog

Let’s face it—2024 has been a wild ride for gaming. And this curated list of must-plays proves that the industry is far from running out of steam. If anything, it's maturing like fine wine.

Critics didn’t just spotlight these games because they’re flashy. They did it because each one offers something special—something memorable. So whether you’ve got a mountain of shame in your backlog or you’re ready to start a brand new save file, these titles deserve a spot on your radar.

Now, all that’s left to do is grab your controller and start playing. You’ve got some masterpieces waiting for you.